CIS 4203 – IT Strategy and IT Governance Assignment
{`Program Computer and Information Science Division (CIS)
Course CIS 4203 – IT Strategy and IT Governance
Higher Colleges of Technology
`}
Case Assessment 1
Introduction
Chapter 2 discusses the following examples of IT governance reference models, frameworks and standards:
- ISO 9001
- Six Sigma
- ISO/IEC 27001
- CMMI
- CobiT
- TOGAF
- ITIL
Task
Your task is to research one of the frameworks listed above and present your findings to the class.
In groups of 2 or 3 students:
- Choose one of the frameworks listed above.
- Research to find articles, textbooks and other references on the topic. You must find at least 3 references – One reference for each person in the group.
- Prepare a presentation.
- Your presentation should start by describing the framework that you chose and its intended area of use.
- Your presentation should then discuss the main elements of the selected framework.
- The presentation should not exceed 10 min.
- Each student should be prepared to answer questions about the discussed framework.
- Choose another group, and prepare a question about their selected framework
PRESENTATION/DISCUSSION RUBRIC Individual
Name _ ____Topic :____
|
CRITERIA |
4 Mastery 90-100% |
3 Above Standard 80 -89% |
2 Standard 70-79% |
1 Approaches Standard 60 -69% |
0 Below Standard 0 -59% |
Marks |
|
Knowledge of topic 25 marks |
-student provides exceptionally detailed and accurate information for at least 5 minutes |
-student provides proficient details and accurate information |
- student provides adequate information that is accurate but needs more details |
-student provides few details or inaccurate or irrelevant information |
-student provides a few details or inaccurate or irrelevant information | |
|
Understanding of Topic 25 marks |
-student clearly understood the topic in-depth and presented information forcefully and convincingly for at least 5 min. |
-student clearly understood the topic in- depth and presented information with ease. |
-student seemed to understand the main points of the topic and presented those with ease. |
-student seemed to understand the main points of the topic, but didn’t present with ease |
-student did not show an adequate understanding of the topic | |
|
Organization 15 marks |
-All material was clearly tied to an idea (premise) and organized in a tight, logical fashion with at least 1 reference per student. |
- Most of the material was clearly tied to an idea (premise) and organized in a tight, logical fashion with references provided |
- Organized and generally complete presentation of material |
- Somewhat organized presentation of material |
- material is unorganized, incomplete, or completely lacking in evidence | |
|
Communication 15 marks |
- student exceptionally expresses ideas clearly and concisely to audience in confident manner - student skilfully varies pitch, tone, uses humour and appropriate language to convince audience |
- student speaks clearly and confidently to audience -student uses appropriate language, volume, tone and humour to convince audience |
- student needs to speak more clearly and confidently - adequate use of language, volume, tone to convince audience |
- often hard to hear student or student seem lost or confused -student needs to used volume, tone to be more convincing |
- hard to hear student or student seem lost or confused -student needs to used volume, tone to be more convincing | |
|
Questions and Discussion 20 marks |
- clear and thorough preparation for discussion and questions asked by the class. -student asked at least one prepared question to another group in the class about their topic. |
- student has prepared for discussion and questions and answers proficiently with evidence -student asked at least one relevant question about another topic. |
- adequate preparation for discussion and questions but could have done better -student made a relevant comment during class discussion. |
- student seems totally unprepared for discussion and questions -student did not participate in class discussion. |
- student totally unprepared for discussion and questions -student did not participate in class discussion. | |
|
Comments |
Total Full Mark= 100 | |||||
